Monday, March 4, 2024

‘Splintered’ Court Ruling Throws J6 Prosecution Into Chaos

‘Splintered’ Court Ruling Throws J6 Prosecution Into Chaos


A Massachusetts man on Friday was charged with a felony related to his participation in the protest at the Capitol on January 6, 2021. Mark Sahady already faced misdemeanors for his nonviolent and brief jaunt through the building that afternoon, but the Justice Department decided to add the common “obstruction of an official proceeding” charge to Sahady’s case on April 7.

That same day, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia threw Sahady—and more than 300 January 6 defendants charged with the same obstruction felony—a potential lifeline. In what one judge described as a “splintered decision,” a three-judge panel narrowly reversed a lower court ruling that tossed the obstruction count against three Capitol protesters. D.C. District Court Judge Carl Nichols dismissed the charge last year largely based on the argument that the statute “requires that the defendant have taken some action with respect to a document, record, or other object in order to corruptly obstruct, impede or influence an official proceeding.”

A fair reading of the law proves Nichols is correct. Passed in 2002 in the wake of the Enron scandal as part of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, section 1512(c)(2) closed a legal loophole related to evidence tampering. The law applies to “whoever corruptly . . . otherwise obstructs, influences, or impedes any official proceeding, or attempts to do so.” It’s a crime punishable by up to 20 years in prison.

When he signed the bill into law in 2002, President George W. Bush, as I explained here, noted that the word “corruptly” would compel the government to prove a defendant’s “criminal state of mind” and the overall provision must not infringe “on the constitutional right to petition the Government for redress of grievances.”

But that hasn’t prevented Attorney General Merrick Garland from weaponizing the statute in exactly that way for more than two years. Dozens of defendants have pleaded guilty or been convicted at trial. Jacob Chansley, the “QAnon Shaman,” spent months in solitary confinement and was denied bail before Garland’s prosecutors successfully tormented him into pleading guilty to obstruction. Judge Royce Lamberth, who repeatedly denied his release, sentenced Chansley to 41 months in prison.

Judge Trevor McFadden repeatedly denied the release of Timothy Hale, a January 6 protester who faced the obstruction count and assorted misdemeanors. Hale spent 16 months in the D.C. gulag under McFadden’s pretrial detention orders before finally going to trial in May 2022. He was convicted by a D.C. jury in a matter of hours and is now serving out a 48-month prison sentence.

When Matthew Perna discovered the government would seek years in federal prison after he pleaded guilty to the obstruction charge, he hanged himself in his garage in February 2022.

In fact, every judge on the D.C. District Court has uniformly denied motions to dismiss the obstruction charge. So when Nichols courageously bucked his colleagues’ groupthink, the Justice Department appealed. Oral arguments were presented in December. Nicholas Smith, currently defending Ethan Nordean in the Proud Boys seditious conspiracy trial, represented the January 6 defendants in the appeal.

At the very least, the clear-as-mud opinion handed down by the appellate panel underscores the conformity, if not sheer laziness, of the district judges’ arguments. The 107-page order takes a number of legal twists and turns before reaching what is essentially three different opinions.

In reversing Nichols’ order, Judge Florence Pan, appointed to the appellate bench by Joe Biden in March 2021, concluded that “the meaning of the statute is unambiguous.” Pan explained why the charge should stick—at least in the cases of the three defendants named in the appeal who also face assault charges. 

“The statutory definition of ‘official proceeding’ under 1512(c)(2) includes a ‘proceeding before the Congress,’” Pan wrote. “Although [January 6 defendants] strain to argue that the Electoral College vote certification is not a ‘proceeding before the Congress’ because it does not involve ‘investigations and evidence,’ we see no such limit in the ordinary meaning of the word ‘proceeding.’”

Pan admitted that “outside of the January 6 cases brought in this jurisdiction, there is no precedent for using 1512(c)(2) to prosecute the type of conduct at issue in this case.” In other words—before the four-hour disturbance at the Capitol that only briefly delayed a ceremonial congressional function—in its 20-year history, the law had never before been used to prosecute political protest.

Nonetheless, she confidently concluded that “restraint and lenity therefore have no place in our analysis.”

Much of the controversy in the opinion centered on the legal interpretation of the word “corruptly.” Judge Justin R. Walker, a Trump appointee, added a detailed caveat to his partial concurrence. “If I did not read ‘corruptly’ narrowly, I would join the dissenting opinion,” Walker explained. “I would give ‘corruptly’ its long-standing meaning. It requires a defendant to act ‘with an intent to procure an unlawful benefit either for himself or for some other person.’ Because I read ‘corruptly’ as courts have read it for hundreds of years—and only because I read it that way—I concur in the Court’s judgment.”

And therein lies the big headache for the Justice Department. What, for example, was the “unlawful benefit” Chansley sought during his peaceful walk through the Capitol on January 6? Or Matthew Perna’s? Or Mark Sahady’s?

Judge George Katsas, also appointed by Trump, in his 43-page dissent, attempted to force the government to answer those questions. “Document destruction readily conjures up images of corporate fraud,” Katsas wrote. “Advocacy, lobbying, and protest do not. For that matter, neither does assaulting police officers or rioting in the Capitol.”

Katsas further noted the Justice Department’s novel use of the statute. “1512(c)(2) has been on the books for two decades and charged in thousands of cases—yet until the prosecutions arising from the January 6 riot, it was uniformly treated as an evidence-impairment crime,” Katsas wrote. “[Until] the January 6 prosecutions, courts had no occasion to consider whether it sweeps more broadly, because all the caselaw had involved conduct plainly intended to hinder the flow of truthful evidence to a proceeding.”

Katsas pointed to sentencing similarities to show how obstruction of an official proceeding is comparable to evidence destruction crimes rather than disrupting a government function. 

“For example, picketing, parading, or using a sound truck to influence a proceeding carries a one-year maximum penalty,” Katsas wrote. “Using threats or force generally carries a maximum penalty of either 5 or 10 years, depending on whether the proceeding is before a court, an agency, or Congress. And destroying, manipulating, or falsifying evidence carries a maximum penalty of 20 years.” That is the same potential sentence for the obstruction felony. 

In fact, the misdemeanor resulting in the most plea agreements in the January 6 prosecution is “parading” in the Capitol, a petty offense punishable by up to six months in jail.

While most of the corporate news media cheered the messy outcome as a win for the Justice Department, the government certainly knows better. Defense attorneys in the ongoing Proud Boys trial, which should conclude this week, filed motions to dismiss the obstruction counts against their clients or at least force the court to use Walker’s narrow definition of “corruptly” in jury instructions. 

Carmen Hernandez, public defender for Zachary Rehl, a member of the Proud Boys, emphasized the perplexing nature of the appellate court’s ruling. “With all due respect to the Circuit Judges, it is extraordinary that Judge Pan and Judge Walker each assert that their opinion controls while disagreeing on the essential issues in the case. The result is an extraordinarily confusing decision that creates more vagueness than it resolves.”

Nicholas Smith argued that “the section as a whole, related statutes, canons of construction, and statutory history all run contrary to the government’s unprecedented argument that 1512(c) reaches acts that have no connection to evidence impairment.”

The Justice Department intentionally exploited the statute’s vague language while ignoring its context, and the D.C. District Court, with the exception of Judge Nichols, allowed it for more than two years. More than 300 individuals—many of whom committed no violent crime—now stand in the middle of a legal and judicial quagmire created by prosecutors and judges in the nation’s capital as the matter almost certainly winds its way to the Supreme Court.

True justice will only be served when gutless judges on the district court finally start to toss this bogus charge or the higher court delivers a well-deserved smackdown in a final decision. It is, of course, too late to save those defendants whose lives have been destroyed (or ended) over the Justice Department’s dishonest and vengeful use of this law.

----------------------------------
Julie Kelly is a political commentator and senior contributor to American Greatness. She is the author of January 6: How Democrats Used the Capitol Protest to Launch a War on Terror Against the Political Right and Disloyal Opposition: How the NeverTrump Right Tried―And Failed―To Take Down the President. Her past work can be found at The Federalist and National Review. She also has been featured in the Wall Street Journal, The Hill, Chicago Tribune, Forbes, and Genetic Literacy Project. She is the co-host of the “Happy Hour Podcast with Julie and Liz.” She is a graduate of Eastern Illinois University and lives in suburban Chicago with her husband and two daughters.
---------------------------------------
Source

https://amgreatness.com/2023/04/11/splintered-court-ruling-throws-j6-prosecution-into-chaos/

Sunday, March 3, 2024

Technocensorship: When Corporations Serve as a Front for Government Censors

Technocensorship: When Corporations Serve as a Front for Government Censors

“Once a government is committed to the principle of silencing the voice of opposition, it has only one way to go, and that is down the path of increasingly repressive measures, until it becomes a source of terror to all its citizens and creates a country where everyone lives in fear. We must, therefore, be on our guard against extremists who urge us to adopt police state measures. Such persons advocate breaking down the guarantees of the Bill of Rights in order to get at the communists. They forget that if the Bill of Rights were to be broken down, all groups, even the most conservative, would be in danger from the arbitrary power of government.”—Harry S. Truman, Special Message to the Congress on the Internal Security of the United States (August 8, 1950)

Nothing good can come from allowing the government to sidestep the Constitution.

Unfortunately, the government has become an expert at disregarding constitutional roadblocks intended to protect the rights of the citizenry.

When these end-runs don’t suffice, the government hides behind the covert, clandestine, classified language of national security; or obfuscates, complicates, stymies, and bamboozles; or creates manufactured diversions to keep the citizenry in the dark; or works through private third parties not traditionally bound by the Constitution.

This last tactic is increasingly how the government gets away with butchering our freedoms, by having its corporate partners serve as a front for its nefarious deeds.

This is how the police state has managed to carry out an illegal secret dragnet surveillance program on the American people over the course of multiple presidential administrations.

Relying on a set of privacy loopholes, the White House (under Presidents Obama, Trump and now Biden) has been sidestepping the Fourth Amendment by paying AT&T to allow federal, state, and local law enforcement to access—without a warrant—the phone records of Americans who are not suspected of a crime.

The government used a similar playbook to get around the First Amendment, packaged as an effort to control the spread of speculative or false information in the name of national security.

As the House Judiciary Select Subcommittee on Weaponization of the Federal Government revealed, the Biden administration worked in tandem with social media companies to censor content related to COVID-19, including humorous jokes, credible information and so-called disinformation.

Likening the government’s heavy-handed attempts to pressure social media companies to suppress content critical of COVID vaccines or the election to “an almost dystopian scenario,” Judge Terry Doughty warned that “the United States Government seems to have assumed a role similar to an Orwellian ‘Ministry of Truth.’”

Restricting access to social media has become a popular means of internet censorship.

Dare to voice politically incorrect views in anything louder than a whisper on social media and you might find yourself suspended on Twitter, shut out of Facebook, and banned across various social media platforms. This authoritarian intolerance masquerading as tolerance, civility and love is what comedian George Carlin referred to as “fascism pretending to be manners.”

Social media censorship runs the gamut from content blocking, throttling, and filtering to lockouts, shutdowns, shadow banning and de-platforming.

In fact, these tactics are at the heart of several critical cases before the U.S. Supreme Court over who gets to control, regulate or remove what content is shared on the internet: the individual, corporate censors or the government.

Yet what those who typically champion the right of corporations to be free from government meddling get wrong about these cases is that there can be no free speech when corporations such as Facebook, Google or YouTube become a front for—or extensions of—government censors.

This is the very definition of technocensorship.

On paper—under the First Amendment, at least—we are technically free to speak.

In reality, however, we are now only as free to speak as a government official—or corporate entities such as Facebook, Google or YouTube—may allow.

Clothed in tyrannical self-righteousness, technocensorship is powered by technological behemoths (both corporate and governmental) working in tandem to achieve a common goal: to muzzle, silence and altogether eradicate any speech that runs afoul of the government’s own approved narrative.

This is political correctness taken to its most chilling and oppressive extreme.

This authoritarian impulse to censor and silence “dangerous” speech masquerading as tolerance, civility and a concern for safety (what comedian George Carlin referred to as “fascism pretending to be manners”) is the end result of a politically correct culture that has become radicalized, institutionalized and tyrannical.

You see, the government is not protecting us from “dangerous” disinformation campaigns. It is laying the groundwork to insulate us from “dangerous” ideas that might cause us to think for ourselves and, in so doing, challenge the power elite’s stranglehold over our lives.

Thus far, the tech giants have been able to sidestep the First Amendment by virtue of their non-governmental status, but it’s a dubious distinction at best when they are marching in lockstep with the government’s dictates.

As Philip Hamburger and Jenin Younes write for The Wall Street Journal: “The First Amendment prohibits the government from ‘abridging the freedom of speech.’ Supreme Court doctrine makes clear that government can’t constitutionally evade the amendment by working through private companies.”

It remains to be seen whether the Supreme Court can see itself clear to recognizing that censorship by social media companies acting at the behest of the government runs afoul of the First Amendment.

Bottom line: either we believe in free speech or we don’t.

The answer to the political, legal and moral challenges of our day should always be more speech, not less.

Any individual or group—prominent or not—who is censored, silenced and made to disappear from Facebook, Twitter, YouTube and Instagram for voicing ideas that are deemed politically incorrect, hateful, dangerous or conspiratorial should be cause for alarm across the entire political spectrum.

To ignore the long-term ramifications of such censorship is dangerously naïve, because whatever powers the government and its corporate operatives are allowed to claim now will eventually be used against the populace at large.

These social shunning tactics borrow heavily from the mind control tactics used by authoritarian cults as a means of controlling its members. As Dr. Steven Hassan writes in Psychology Today: “By ordering members to be cut off, they can no longer participate. Information and sharing of thoughts, feelings, and experiences are stifled. Thought-stopping and use of loaded terms keep a person constrained into a black-and-white, all-or-nothing world. This controls members through fear and guilt.”

This mind control can take many forms, but the end result is an enslaved, compliant populace incapable of challenging tyranny.

As Rod Serling, creator of The Twilight Zone, once observed, “We’re developing a new citizenry, one that will be very selective about cereals and automobiles, but won’t be able to think.”

The problem is that we’ve allowed ourselves to be persuaded that we need someone else to think and speak for us, and we’ve bought into the idea that we need the government and its corporate partners to shield us from that which is ugly or upsetting or mean. The result is a society in which we’ve stopped debating among ourselves, stopped thinking for ourselves, and stopped believing that we can fix our own problems and resolve our own differences.

In short, we have reduced ourselves to a largely silent, passive, polarized populace incapable of working through our own problems and reliant on the government to protect us from our fears.

As Nat Hentoff, that inveterate champion of the First Amendment, once observed, “The quintessential difference between a free nation, as we profess to be, and a totalitarian state, is that here everyone, including a foe of democracy, has the right to speak his mind.”

What this means is championing the free speech rights of those with whom we might disagree.

That’s why James Madison, the author of the Bill of Rights, fought for a First Amendment that protected the “minority” against the majority, ensuring that even in the face of overwhelming pressure, a minority of one—even one who espouses distasteful viewpoints—would still have the right to speak freely, pray freely, assemble freely, challenge the government freely, and broadcast his views in the press freely. He understood that freedom for those in the unpopular minority constitutes the ultimate tolerance in a free society.

The government has no tolerance for freedom or free speech of any kind that challenges its chokehold on power.

At some point or another, depending on how the government and its corporate allies define what constitutes “disinformation,” “hate” or “extremism, “we the people” might all be considered guilty of some thought crime or speech transgression or other.

Yet as I make clear in my book Battlefield America: The War on the American People and in its fictional counterpart The Erik Blair Diaries, it’s a slippery slope from censoring so-called illegitimate ideas to silencing truth.

Eventually, as George Orwell predicted, telling the truth will become a revolutionary act.

Ultimately, the government’s war on free speech—and that’s exactly what it is—is a war that is driven by a government fearful of its people.

As President John F. Kennedy observed, “[A] nation that is afraid to let its people judge the truth and falsehood in an open market is a nation that is afraid of its people.”

Reprinted with permission from The Rutherford Institute.

Saturday, March 2, 2024

Trudeau gov’t set to introduce another internet regulation bill this week

Trudeau gov’t set to introduce another internet regulation bill this week


Send an urgent message to Canadian legislators urging them to stop more online censorship laws

OTTAWA, Ontario (LifeSiteNews) — Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s Liberal government is introducing its “online harms” legislation this week, spurring fears that this may mean the revival of parts of a lapsed bill from 2021 which looked to target free speech by banning certain legal internet content. 

The new bill, by Liberal Justice Minister Arif Virani, was posted on the House of Commons notice paper for February 26, 2024, and will soon be read in Parliament. 

The Online Harms Act will modify existing laws, amending the Criminal Code as well as the Canadian Human Rights Act, in what the Trudeau Liberals claim will target certain cases of internet content removal, notably those involving child sexual abuse and pornography.  

The new bill will also create an ombudsperson who will be charged with dealing with public complaints regarding online content, as well as put forth a regulatory function that will be charged with monitoring internet platform behaviors.  

While the Trudeau government claims the bill is being created to protect kids, Conservative Party of Canada head Pierre Poilievre said that the federal government is looking for clever ways to enact internet censorship laws.  

During a February 21 press conference, Poilievre said that Trudeau is looking to, in effect, criminalize speech he does not like. 

“What does Justin Trudeau mean when he says the word ‘hate speech?’ He means speech he hates,” said Poilievre. 

Virani had many times last year hinted that a new Online Harms Act bill would be forthcoming in 2024.  

Many fear that the new bill will be similar to the failed June 2021 bill introduced by then-Justice Minister David Lametti. Lametti had introduced Bill 36, “An Act to amend the Criminal Code and the Canadian Human Rights Act and to make related amendments to another Act (hate propaganda, hate crimes and hate speech),”  which was blasted as a controversial “hate speech” law that would give police the power to “do something” about online “hate.”

It was feared that if passed, it would target bloggers and social media users for speaking their minds.  

Bill C-36 included text to amend Canada’s Criminal Code and Human Rights Act to define “hatred” as “the emotion that involves detestation or vilification and that is stronger than dislike or disdain (haine).”  

If passed, the bill would have theoretically allow a tribunal to judge anyone who has a complaint of online “hate” leveled against them, even if he has not committed a crime. If found guilty, the person would have been in violation of the new law and could have faced fines of up to $70,000 as well as house arrest.  

Two other Trudeau bills dealing with freedom as it relates to the internet have become law, the first being  Bill C-11, or the Online Streaming Act, which mandates that Canada’s broadcast regulator the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission (CRTC) oversee regulating online content on platforms such as YouTube and Netflix to ensure that such platforms are promoting content in accordance with a variety of its guidelines.  

Trudeau’s other internet censorship law, the Online News Act, was passed by the Senate in June of last year.    

The Online News Act  mandated that Big Tech companies pay to publish Canadian content on their platforms. As a result, Meta, the parent company of Facebook and Instagram, has blocked all access to news content in Canada.

Critics of Trudeau’s recent laws, such as tech mogul Elon Musk, have said it shows that “Trudeau is trying to crush free speech in Canada.”   

Send an urgent message to Canadian legislators urging them to stop more online censorship laws

--------------------------------------------

Source

https://www.lifesitenews.com/news/trudeau-govt-set-to-introduce-another-internet-regulation-bill-this-week/?utm_source=digest-canadian-2024-02-28&utm_medium=email

Friday, March 1, 2024

That's how I lost faith in the mainstream media

That's how I lost faith in the mainstream media

Helmut Scheben /  

When news later turns out to be false, it is often already burned into the memory as "historical truth".

During and after the 1991 Gulf War, the media in the U.S. was prohibited from photographing or filming images of coffins of dead U.S. soldiers. The measure was only lifted in February 2009. Filming dead or wounded U.S. soldiers was also banned, and the ban was enforced with extreme severity, especially during the Iraq war, cameramen reported. Once, when I was looking for such recordings in the huge archive of Swiss television, I found a single sequence that lasted about three seconds. An American soldier tried to climb out of a burning tank.

Three seconds of thousands of videos shot in that war. Three seconds that – as can be clearly seen – were due to a mistake by an editor who had set an IN or OUT incorrectly, so that material became visible that should actually have been censored.

Scenes of defeat have not been shown since Vietnam. So there are no more defeats, because the TV news compressed into two and a half minutes is what makes history in our minds

In his 1920 book "Liberty and the News", the American journalist and media theorist Walter Lippmann stated:

"The newspaper columns are public information carriers. If those who control it claim the right to determine what should be reported and for what purpose, then the democratic process comes to a standstill."

(Lippmann, p.24)

Just a few years ago, I couldn't have imagined that my morning walk to the mailbox to get the newspapers would be accompanied by a quiet counterpoint of reluctance and boredom. I like to have paper in my hand for my morning coffee instead of looking at a screen. Reading, however, is decreasing from year to year. On the one hand, this is due to the fact that many topics no longer interest me, for example the eternal soap opera of British royals, the daily obligatory LGBTQ problems, the me-too sensitivity of groupies at rock concerts or parliamentary investigations to find out why banks are hitting the wall in the financial casino.

However, the real problems of most people, the war in Ukraine, the escalating conflict between the USA and China, i.e. events that are currently changing the lives of millions of taxpayers and burdening future generations (rearmament, inflation, energy policy, sanctions policy, asylum, etc.) are presented in our leading media with such a reduced perspective that it leaves me stunned. The denial of reality takes place with a matter-of-factness bordering on rabies.

Out of 100 articles, there are not 5 from the point of view of the other warring party

As an example, I took the trouble to check the Zürcher Tages-Anzeiger, to which I subscribe, for one-sidedness. From Russia's attack in February 2022 to the end of 2022, I looked at around a hundred articles directly about the Ukraine war. By the hundredth report, I was exhausted by the same thing over and over again. Almost all of them describe the suffering and heroism of Western Ukraine in the Russian war of aggression and – in shrill colours – the crimes of Russia.

Connoisseurs of weapons systems and geostrategy incessantly repeat why Russia must be defeated, and the investigators know little more than the hunt for some Russian who could still have their assets expropriated.

For every hundred articles, I didn't find five that informed what was happening on the other side of the front. The suffering of pro-Russian Ukrainians from the missile strikes and artillery fire of pro-Western Ukrainians is not worth mentioning. The people behind the front line don't seem to exist for our big media. It is reported exclusively with the optics of NATO, i.e. with the optics of an armaments lobby that functions worldwide as a crowbar of the United States.

The one-sidedness of the reports stems from the one-sidedness of the sources. In addition to the inevitable British intelligence (whether 007 is cooperating remains in the dark so far), the daily sources of our "notification" are: President Zelensky and his entourage in Kiev, as well as his friends in Brussels, London, Washington and the associated experts and NATO think tanks. The Russians appear mainly as criminals who deny their crimes.

And when a dam breaks that largely floods Russian defensive positions and territory occupied by Russia, all German talk shows, but also the Swiss radio magazine "Echo der Zeit", immediately find experts who know that it was the Russians who destroyed the dam. Just as it is the Russians who are shooting at themselves in the nuclear power plant they occupy. "Tis the times' plague, when madmen lead the blind," says Shakespeare in King Lear.

In the years leading up to the Russian attack, OECD observers recorded daily artillery detonations, and in February 2022, hundreds of explosions per day. The fighting in eastern Ukraine between 2014 and 2022 has claimed far more than ten thousand lives. So this war didn't start in February 2022.

Have our newspapers reported on it? They have largely swept it under the carpet. They only see what they already know. This means that they always know what they are going to see. In other words, what I can read in the newspapers every morning. And thus what I don't have to read anymore because I already know what it is before I open the newspaper.

"Don't be fooled by your own"

In the autumn of 1983, more than a million people demonstrated all over the Federal Republic of Germany against the stationing of atomic bombs. Even in several countries that were members of NATO, a majority of people opposed further nuclear armament, because it was clear that the much-vaunted "balance of terror" had long been guaranteed by the British and French A-bombs. During the debate in the Bundestag, opposition leader Willy Brandt said that his party, the SPD, was being bombarded with letters of protest:

"These are West Germans and East Germans, these are Europeans and Americans, these are mothers and fathers, grandmothers and grandfathers, workers and entrepreneurs, artists and soldiers, housewives, pensioners, and there are scientists and engineers of all academic degrees. I wonder who benefits if the commitment and collective expertise of these fellow citizens is thrown away with all the arrogance of power."

The FDP-CDU majority in the German parliament voted for the people's vote in the garbage can and decided to station nuclear medium-range missiles. Although these were abolished as part of a disarmament agreement, US nuclear warheads are now stored at Büchel Air Base in the Eifel region. German Air Force pilots train their use as part of so-called "nuclear sharing". It is no military secret that Russia has always been, and still is, the main target.

In the same year, 1983, Christa Wolf's book "Kassandra" was published, a text about a seer who, before her death, reflects on the downfall of her homeland Troy:

"You can know when the war will begin, but when will the pre-war begin? If there were rules, they would have to be passed on. To bury in clay in stone, to pass it on. What would it say? Among other sentences, it would read: Don't be deceived by your own."

I let myself be deceived by my own, but it took me a long time to realize it. The "Süddeutsche Zeitung", the "Frankfurter Rundschau", the "Neue Zürcher", the "Spiegel" and other newspapers were my leading media when I learned journalism.

The big media, both fee-financed and private, have failed miserably in all the wars I've witnessed. Their job would have been to question the actions of governments, but they have in many cases proven to be loudspeakers of government propaganda and warmongers in unjustified and senseless wars.

The Balkan Wars opened Pandora's box

My first major professional crisis, if I remember correctly, came during the Balkan Wars. I couldn't sleep at night when I realized that the blue was being lied down from the sky. Tuzla was my key experience at the time. The city in Bosnia was defined as a safe zone in 1993. Blue helmets were stationed there. The Bosnian Muslim population was to be protected from Serbian attacks. Nevertheless, the Serbian artillery fired on the city. These attacks were daily news on the radio news for months. The Western media was overflowing with outrage over the shelling of the safe area.

I fell out of the clouds when, in 1995, peacekeepers told me: "The Serbs sometimes shoot in there, but the artillery in Tuzla also shoots out every night at the surrounding Serbian villages."

Tuzla was supplied with weapons by the United States at night and in the fog. There were restricted military areas where UN units were denied access. The same government in Washington that outwardly played the role of "honest broker" to bring about an end to the war secretly organized so-called "black flights" to arm the Bosniak military.

When a Norwegian peacekeeper officer noticed this in 1995 and made it public, he was ordered to remain silent and was transferred as a punishment. The British broadcaster ITN/Channel 4 had filmed a report about the matter, which I took over for a magazine of the SRG programme Switzerland 4.

My attempts to draw the attention of the Swiss media to the revelations were met with indifference. In Bosnia as well as in Kosovo, NATO determined what could and could not be known. Carla Del Ponte, chief prosecutor in The Hague, later complained that she ran into a wall with her request for access to NATO's secret operations.

It wasn't until much later that I learned that leading U.S. PR agencies were feeding the press with horror stories about Serbian concentration camps and Holocaust plans, which a gigantic media apparatus was chasing around the world in a matter of seconds. In their study "Operation Balkans: Advertising for War and Death", the political scientists Jörg Becker and Mira Beham have found well over a hundred such PR contracts in US archives. The mission was to portray the Serbs as perpetrators and the others as victims. James Harff, head of PR agency Ruder Finn, described his job as follows:

"Our craft is to spread news, to circulate it as quickly as possible (...) Speed is crucial. Because we know very well that the first message matters. A denial no longer has any effect."

Mira Beham: War Drums. Media, War and Politics. 1996. p.172 ff.

PR agencies make the case for war and death

Harff showed a certain professional pride to Jacques Merlino, a deputy editor-in-chief of France 2, when he candidly described how his agency did its job "with a great bluff" by getting three powerful Jewish lobby organizations in the United States to warn of an impending Holocaust in the Balkans in advertisements in the New York Times.

"With one move, we were able to simplify things and present them as a story of the good guys and the bad guys (...) And we won, because we chose the right target, the Jewish audience. Immediately, there was a noticeable change in the use of language in the media, accompanied by the use of terms that had a strong emotional charge, such as ethnic cleansing, concentration camps, and so on, and all this evokes a comparison with Nazi Germany, gas chambers and Auschwitz. The emotional charge was so powerful that no one dared to argue with it."

Consequently, German Foreign Minister Joschka Fischer toured Europe with the slogan "Never again Auschwitz" and his Defense Minister Scharping told the people that it was known that the Serbs "play football with the severed heads of their enemies." A photo that went around the world as proof of Serbian atrocities and as an argument for NATO's war of aggression showed a horribly emaciated man with a naked torso behind barbed wire. It was reminiscent of the photos of German extermination camps in 1945. The recording was – as was later proven – a fake. At that time, the Trnopolje refugee centre in question was not cordoned off by a barbed wire fence, nor were there any half-starved people there.

Nothing has changed. The war generates the same propaganda tools over and over again. In 2022, a "writer from East Germany" living in Ukraine named Christoph Brumme wrote a regular "diary" in the "NZZ am Sonntag" in which he predicted, among other things, that the Russians would set up concentration camps in Ukraine and that Putin was a second Hitler. He was probably seriously ill and would stage his suicide with an atomic bomb. And so on.

The category of "embedded journalists" had already emerged during the Gulf War of 1991, and there is hardly a term that better describes how this profession can degenerate into a kind of prostitution. In his study "Second Front: Censorship and propaganda in the 1991 Gulf War German", US journalist John R. MacArthur has shown how the media was kept on a leash and how the public was deceived.

The symbiosis of the big media and their governments became completely self-evident after the attack of 9/11. This was defined as an attack by an enemy power and, according to this logic, first attacked Afghanistan, then Iraq. A "war on terror" was launched worldwide, and once the clean-up was underway, "oppressed peoples were liberated" in Libya and Syria as well. The results can be seen in all these countries.

As early as 1987, the renowned science journalist and peace activist Norman Cousins gave the ideological mission of the superpower USA a name: "The Pathology of Power".

A fabricated rape story in Libya

It is incomprehensible to me how journalists, who have so often been lied to by governments, continue to spread the political prescriptions from above as if they were the tablets of the Ten Commandments. In June 2011, U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton told the cameras that she now had proof that Libyan ruler Muammar Gaddafi was using "systematic rape" as a strategy. At that time, civil war was raging in Libya. The Libyan army tried to put down an uprising that had escalated in the wake of the so-called "Arab Spring" since February 2011. The U.S. and its NATO allies have been bombing the country since March 2011 in order to help the Libyan people oppressed by Gaddafi and "enforce a no-fly zone," according to the official argument.

Living proof of the accusation of rape was a Libyan woman named Eman-al Obeidi. The woman had gained access to the luxury hotel Rixos Al Nasr in Tripoli on March 26, 2011. Hotel staff and security guards tried to prevent her from making contact with the journalists who were sitting there at breakfast. The woman screamed that she had been kidnapped and raped by Gaddafi's militiamen at a checkpoint three days earlier.

Libyan government spokesman Musa Ibrahim later said that Ms. Obeidi was initially thought to be intoxicated and mentally disturbed. Then it was established that their statements were credible. The case is in the hands of the judiciary. It is an ordinary crime and not a political crime.

Ms. Obeidi has been interviewed by CNN and numerous other media outlets. It figured as proof of the wickedness of the Libyan head of state, Gaddafi. The major media hardly thought it worth mentioning that Libyan doctors had cared for the woman, had confirmed the rape and that the Libyan police had arrested suspects shortly afterwards.

In 2011, at an Amnesty International office in Zurich, I asked what was true about the allegations. I was told that Amnesty had been investigating Libya for several months and had found no confirmation of the allegation of mass rape. The spokesman for the Libyan organization Human Rights Solidarity Libya, which was close to the insurgents, also told me on the phone: "We have no evidence. The only concrete case is that of Ms. Obeidi."

In the meantime, the crap had gone on and the story experienced an almost frenzied proliferation in practically all Western media. My Google search on Sunday, July 20, 2011, showed 21 million results. The chief prosecutor of the International Criminal Court in The Hague, Luis Moreno Ocampo, provided an excellent lubricant for the media apparatus by remarking that he did indeed have "information" about mass rape. When asked by a journalist what he thought of reports that Gaddafi had Viagra imported so that his soldiers could rape, the chief prosecutor did not reply: "Leave me alone with such nonsense." Instead, he said the perfidious sentence that evidence was still being collected: "Yes, we are still collecting evidence."

The fantasy continued to proliferate for weeks. The Swiss newspaper "Le Matin" took the creative story-telling to the point of photographing a king-size bed with lamp and bedside table: supposedly a room in an underground bunker where, according to the paper, Gaddafi abused his female victims. During this time, I have not met a journalist who said that he was ashamed of the fact that his career choice made him part of this industry.

"Atrocity Management" is as old as war itself.

The demonization of the enemy is a tried and tested instrument that is as old as war itself.

In his standard work "Images of War, War of Images", the historian Gerhard Paul used more than 200 illustrations to illustrate how modern visual media burned war into the collective memory as iconography. According to Gerhard Paul, reality is lost to the same extent as the images are perfected and standardized.

Crimes against children are always effective in the media. This ranges from Kuwaiti "nurse Najirah," who told a U.S. Congressional Human Rights Committee that she had seen Iraqi soldiers tear out the tubes of incubator babies, which later turned out to be an invention of the PR agency Hill & Knowlton, to the human rights commissioner Denisova in Kyiv, who lost her job in June 2022 because it became clear that she had spread lies. Among them is the claim that she has evidence that Russian soldiers raped small children.

The portrayal of the enemy as a bestial monster seems an unavoidable stereotype of war propaganda. During the First World War, the story that German soldiers had snatched a baby from a Belgian woman, chopped off his hands and then eaten it was a perennial favorite in the French and British press.

When the enemy is a monster that embodies evil itself, wars are easier to justify. In more than forty years of journalistic work, I have had to realize that the major media usually disseminate such propaganda narratives uncritically and are only very late or never willing to admit their mistakes. The New York Times, which asked its readers for forgiveness for misinformation about the Iraq war, is the only case I know of.

In 19 years of working at Swiss television SRF, I have not heard of any case in which a programme has apologised for false news. With the exception of the Meteo broadcast, when the weather forecast was wrong.

In 2011, I drew the attention of Amnesty International Switzerland to the fact that there were no television images of the destruction caused by NATO air strikes in Libya. The Libyan government's television studios were reduced to rubble in the first wave of attacks. As a result, the NATO command center in Naples was able to prevent emotional images of victims pulled from the rubble from being shown on Western TV channels. The major media didn't notice the problem, or they ignored it.

The Amnesty spokesperson replied to me at the time that they were also very concerned about this one-sidedness of the presentation. In the evening, when I had finished the report for the Tagesschau with the editor at the editing suite, the head of the Tages, said at the acceptance that this sentence of the Amnesty spokesman had to be removed from the report. When I asked him why, he said: "Otherwise the audience might think that Gaddafi is not so evil and that he is still in the right in the end."

A new era of censorship has dawned

The corporate media and the fee-financed broadcasters dominate the news market. They all claim to be the Fourth Estate, which keeps a close eye on the powerful, and that this is what makes democracy possible in the first place. My experience is that they are much more believers in a kind of religious community that sees itself as an axis of good. Anyone who does not want to share their worldview is hushed up, defamed or simply banned.

In this sense, governments and their media are working efficiently. The 27 countries of the European Union have banned the Russian news channels RT and Sputnik. Anyone who disseminates or receives them can even pay a fine of up to 50,000 euros in Austria. That's how easy it is to believe that the simplicity of opinion can be enforced. Protest or criticism from the major editorial offices of the Fourth Estate? Zero.

While this war is discussed controversially on Russian social media* with astonishing harshness, Western media are trying to drum into us with obsessive diligence that anyone in Russia who says anything against this war will be imprisoned. "Ten years in prison for thinking" is the headline of the Neue Zürcher Zeitung (6 June 2023).

In Kiev, opposition media are simply banned. Is it necessary to report on it? Obviously not. This is then dealt with casually, almost as a digressive detour, in eight words: "Since the beginning of the war, Ukrainian broadcasters have been showing a joint program" (Zürcher Tagesanzeiger, 28 July 2022). Programme? It almost sounds like community service.

There is a system to concealment. Nowhere is this more evident than in the silence that our leading media maintain about the rampant censorship of social media. A few weeks after the EU banned Russian broadcasters, Google announced that it would block all Russian-linked media worldwide. As is often the case with Big Tech, the pressure allegedly came from the company's own workforce: "Google employees had urged YouTube to take additional punitive measures against Russian channels."

Millions of posts disappear from the platform. Investigative journalist Glenn Greenwald, who was involved in Edward Snowden's revelations, has pointed out this extreme censorship campaign and the billions of dollars involved:

"It is hardly surprising that the monopolies of Silicon Valley exercise their censorship power in full compliance with the foreign policy interests of the U.S. government. Many of the major tech monopolies – such as Google and Amazon – routinely seek and obtain highly lucrative contracts with the US security apparatus, including the CIA and NSA. Its top managers maintain close ties with top representatives of the Democratic Party. And congressional Democrats have repeatedly summoned tech executives before their various committees to threaten them with legal and regulatory reprisals if they don't make censorship more in line with the party's political goals and interests.

If you read the Twitter Files, you know how the system works. A discreet intervention by the FBI can cause leading media outlets to put politically sensitive issues on hold until the "danger", in this case an election defeat for candidate Joe Biden, is averted.

What shocked me then and still stunned me today is the cauldron that is reflexively set in motion by a media mob when a few dare to swim against the tide and question the published opinion. The political scientist Mira Beham had told me that she had been banned from writing in the Süddeutsche Zeitung because she dared to argue that in the Balkan conflicts one could not get any further with the perpetrator-victim scheme, that the matter was more complex. Nowadays, a renowned journalist like Patrick Baab loses his teaching position at Kiel University if he dares to report from the Donbass "from the wrong side of the front".

Orwell's dystopian vision of "Newspeak" and "Ministries of Truth" is well on its way to becoming reality. We are indeed witnessing a turning point in this respect, even if the German Chancellor meant something different when he used the term.

The word lying press does not describe the matter

The media scientist Uwe Krüger has documented that most of the alpha animals of the established media are members of NATO and US-related institutions. Of course, there is the factor of coercion and adaptation, such as the well-known fact that every employee at Axel Springer Verlag ("Bild", "Die Welt") must agree to the statutes that call for support for the transatlantic alliance and solidarity with the United States.

At the same time, one should be careful with the abusive term "lying press". The matter is infinitely more complicated. On the one hand, as far as the news channels are concerned, there is a system that is based on shortening and excessive speeds. The philosopher Paul Virilio spoke of an "industry of forgetting" that incessantly bombards with new news what has just been reported. A news apparatus that produces highly shredded fragments of events cannot provide contexts and backgrounds, even if well-meaning journalists wanted to.

And they want it. In my entire life, I have hardly met any media people who wanted to falsify or report dishonestly. People don't lie, but they are mostly convinced of what they say and write. Throughout their life history, in their education and in their social contacts, they are shaped and integrated into the worldview of their environment.

There is this "huge chunk of truth" that the Israeli historian Shlomo Sand called "implanted memory":

"We are all born into a universe of fields of discourse that have been shaped by the ideological power struggles of previous generations. Even before the historian can acquire the tools for critical questioning, all the history, politics and Bible lessons at school, the national holidays, commemorative days, public ceremonies, street names, memorials, television series and other spheres of memory form his imagination. There's a huge chunk of 'truth' in his head that he can't just get around."

Shlomo Sand: The Invention of the Jewish People. p. 40

The problem of an industry that is supposed to serve the daily search for truth under the name of journalism is familiar to every magician and sleight of hand: perception is not determined by actual events, but by expectations. Of a huge chunk of "truth".

____________
*Initially, there was also talk of Russian talk shows. However, for some time now, no guests have been invited to these who fundamentally question the war in Ukraine.

____________
This post appeared on GlobalBridge on June 13.

----------------------------------------

Author: Helmut Scheben

Helmut Scheben (*1947 in Koblenz, Germany) studied Romance languages and literature in Mainz, Bonn, Salamanca and Lima. In 1980 he received his doctorate in philosophy. at the University of Bonn. From 1980 to 1985 he worked as a press agency reporter and correspondent for print media in Mexico and Central America. From 1986 he was editor of the weekly newspaper (WoZ) in Zurich, and from 1993 to 2012 editor and reporter at Swiss television SRF, including 16 years in the Tagesschau.

----------------------------------

Source

https://www.infosperber.ch/medien/medienkritik/so-verlor-ich-den-glauben-an-die-etablierten-medien/

Mundane Astrology and Demographics - Gen Z

Mundane Astrology and Demographics - Gen Z ---------------------------------------- Some Astrologers examine Pluto and Neptune placements to...